Skip to main content

Music and the Fictive Dream: The Phantom of the Opera

The Phantom and Christine from the 2005 Broadway Play
"The Phantom of the Opera," initially penned as a gothic mystery novel by Gaston Leroux in 1909, has evolved from its modest origins into cultural phenomenon. It has inspired countless fanfictions, films, and more notably, Broadway musicals. It follows the story of the young talented Christine Daaé, who becomes the obsession of the mysterious phantom. The musical maintains much of the book's gothic and dark romantical elements, but in my opinion, it better translates the fantastical appeal of an opera.   

Phantom of the Opera - 2004
The Novel was transformed into a musical by Andrew Lloyd Weber in 1988. In 2004, the musical was adapted into a film directed by Joel Schumacher, starring Emmy Rossum, Gerard Butler, and Patrick Wilson. This adaptation is among the more popular ones, and its music is what I will be sampling from. The music throughout the film is what drives the film's emotional impact. The vocals, particularly Emmy's, are exceptionally powerful, and her range is impressive. Without her talent and commitment, the scores would not convey as much emotion.

The peak of the film occurs during the number "Past the Point of No Return". Here, the phantom lures Christine Daaé into a passionate and perilous musical climax. The song occurs in the latter part of the musical, when Christine, after being manipulated and lured by the Phantom's mysterious presence and promises, is drawn into his lair for a final confrontation. Out of the musical numbers featured, this accomplishes the most emotionally. Here we see Christine fighting a battle within herself, whether stay in the light, or succumb to the darkness of the Phantom. Christine’s voice, initially fragile and hesitant, grows in intensity as she is drawn deeper into the Phantom’s world. The vocal line moves from a light, lyrical quality into a more operatic and dramatic range, mirroring the increasing stakes. In contrast, the Phantom’s voice is dark and commanding, an embodiment of power and persuasion. 

                                                                                            Past the Point of no Return - Scene from the 2004 Film


 On a personal level, I am struck by how the music not only serves as a tool for storytelling but also evokes a profound emotional response. The haunting, melodic phrases that echo in the orchestration create a sense of inevitability, while Christine’s vocal ascent is both beautiful and tragic. This creates a juxtaposition of conflicting emotions—desire and dread, power and vulnerability—that resonates deeply. The final moment of the song, when Christine succumbs to the Phantom’s will, is chilling both musically and dramatically. What truly does it for me is not the main score, but the final clip of the film. During the finale, previous scores are sampled together with "Past the Point of no Return" to craft an intense ending.
                                                                                                    The Phantom of the Opera 2004 - Finale

Overall, "The Point of No Return" stands as one of the most psychologically complex and musically sophisticated pieces in The Phantom of the Opera, showcasing Webber’s skill in combining musical elements with narrative development. Its themes of manipulation, desire, and loss resonate both in the context of the musical and as broader social commentary.

                                                                             Citations:

The Phantom Pf the Opera Musical Breakdown - Search Videos. www.bing.com/videos/riverview/relatedvideo?q=the+phantom+pf+the+opera+musical+breakdown&mid=A24B28057495260ABF43A24B28057495260ABF43&FORM=VIRE.


Wikipedia contributors. “The Phantom of the Opera (1986 Musical).” Wikipedia, 10 Nov. 2024, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Phantom_of_the_Opera_(1986_musical).


“Phantom of the Opera 2004 Musical Analysis - Bing.” Bing, www.bing.com/search?q=phantom+of+the+opera+2004+musical+analysis&qs=n&sp=-1&lq=0&pq=phantom+of+the+opera+2004+musical+analysis&sc=0-42&sk=&cvid=345B6416554F4B829B879E69D667B041&ghsh=0&ghacc=0&ghpl=&FPIG=C603A2FB30EB4A9C98BDF9AA4B5AE41A&first=11&FORM=PERE.








Comments

  1. Garrett TaylorNovember 20, 2024 at 4:41 PM

    This is one of my favorite musicals/movies to watch. While I have never seen it live, I hope to one day (it saddens me that it is no longer on Broadway). I have not seen it in quite some time but will watch it this weekend lol. I think you would like "Defying Gravity" from Wicked. This is another emotional song that speaks to a character’s sense of freedom and defiance. It's intense, dramatic, and filled with powerful vocals just like this. Or even "The Last Night of the World" from Miss Saigon. It is filled with a sense of desperation and longing, similar to the tension and emotional stakes of "The Point of No Return."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Vashti SkinnerNovember 20, 2024 at 10:22 PM

    I wanted to say that I really liked your ideas about “The Phantom of the Opera.” The encouragement you gave about the emotional display in “Past the Point of No Return” got the conflict between Christine and the Phantom on the best natural without exaggeration. It is strange how this music enhances the tension that exists in their personalities. I look forward to the second time watching the film with what you stated in mind!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I am Eva - MUS Week #3

                                                                I am Eva               Hello! I am Eva. I'm originally from New England, but I have moved pretty much all over. I finally settled in Alaska in 2017, but I hope to move out eventually.  I'm here at UAF to get my associate of arts degree, but after I graduate, I plan to study criminology down in Arizona. Although Alaska has much to offer, I'm afraid it doesn't quite fit me. In the Summer, I like to get out and explore our state by going kayaking, canoeing, and rock climbing, if Summer classes and my job spare me some time:) My favorite place to go during the summer is Homer, but Hatchers Pass is a must during the fall.  Hatcher's Pass I have always had an interest in music, and I feel it started at the young age of six, when my mother signed me up for piano lessons. For almost 10 years, she would sometimes literally drag me out of the house to go. All that stopped during Covid-19, but since then I've
2 comments
Read more

The Waterphone: Evolutions and Origins

Modern Day Waterphone A waterphone, or an ocean harp, is a very unique instrument. It's crafted from a metal resonating bowl with a grip in the center, and prongs along the outer rim. Water can be added to the bowl to change pitch and sound resonance. They are fairly easy to play, although it's difficult to hold melody or rhythm. They can be played either with a bow or percussively. The waterphone creates an eerie shrill hum which has been described as a "sirens song". Its distinct sound has made it be primarily used in sound effects or soundtracks, but several rock musicians have also experimented with it. I've always wanted to play the waterphone, and I love being able to hear its cry in horror movies or in background sounds.                                                                                                                     Waterphone Demonstration But how did this strange instrument come to be? In 1969, an American sculptor and painter known as 
4 comments
Read more

Musical Trip: Exploring Japan through Music

I chose Traditional Japanese music because I've always found it quite soothing and peaceful. It is a fusion of centuries-old cultural history, varied regional influences, and unique musical techniques. Understanding this genre requires an appreciation of its distinctive harmony, rhythms, tempo, and styles. We'll delve into these elements to provide a deeper insight into the unique character of traditional Japanese music. The Japanese word for music is "Ongaku" directly translates to comfort. Music has played a big part in Japanese culture. Since its birth, Japanese music has been a huge part of religious ceremonies, theatrical performances, and communal celebration. There are four main types of traditional music, each with their own unique rhythms, harmonies, and even instruments.           Koto A notable feature of traditional Japanese music is its distinctive approach to harmony.    Unlike  Western music, which often revolves around chord progressions and complex ha
Post a Comment
Read more